N.J. county commissioner says consolidation of elite golf course ‘town’ with neighbor was long overdue

Christopher Inexperienced has never ever played an formal spherical at a person of the premiere golf courses in the planet, which just happens to be in his hometown.

He did enjoy a spherical or two about 30 many years back when he was a caddy at the Pine Valley Golfing Club, a tremendous exceptional, private haunt for the wealthy, well known, and very well linked. But that was when no just one was seeking.

The club, in point, was much more than a club. It was, right until the initially of this calendar year, its very own municipality, with a borough council, police power and a pair of workforce, together with stability guards, to oversee the 600 or so acres of densely wooded hills punctuated by just one of the most coveted shrines of golfing in the environment.

But Environmentally friendly, 60, nevertheless can’t move foot on the property, which is wholly owned by the club – even however he is now mayor of Pine Hill, the borough Pine Valley consolidated with on Jan. 1.

Camden County officials are lauding the consolidation as a cost-saving move that was long overdue.

“Making Camden County a additional reasonably priced position to are living relies on us consolidating companies and decreasing the myriad redundancies in governing administration products and services in very small towns that have less than 100 people,” Camden County Commission Director Louis Cappelli wrote in an e mail to NJ Advance Media. “Basically, it boggles my mind that we had two municipalities that are fundamentally just golf programs with a couple of residences on them.”

The other municipality Cappelli was referring to is Tavistock, which has three homes and a lot less than 10 citizens. It also has a personal golf system, but has a public cafe and banquet hall. It marked its 100th anniversary final 12 months.

On Wednesday, the condition filed a civil legal rights grievance in opposition to Pine Valley Golfing Club, alleging it violated New Jersey’s Legislation Versus Discrimination by banning girls from turning into customers and limiting their means to golfing and to entry club facilities.

When Pine Valley was its have borough, it also correctly limited house ownership to only guys. The director of point out Office of Civil Rights in 2019 experienced peppered then Pine Valley borough officers with questions about “limitations on house ownership,” in accordance to 157 pages of files obtained by NJ Progress Media in 2021.

The club made the decision to allow for females to be customers in 2021, just before the merger with Pine Hill. Point out officers said Wednesday people guidelines altered only right after the state launched its investigation. Club officers did not answer to calls, texts or e-mails in search of remark.

As a end result of the merger with Pine Valley, Pine Hill bought a $10 million tax ratable that has translated into $1 million in more tax earnings this year, stated Green, who spoke to NJ Advance Media ahead of point out officials introduced the submitting of the civil legal rights criticism.

The borough was now supplying municipal companies, such as law enforcement, firefighters and EMS, as section of a shared provider settlement for the people of much less than two dozen households in the former Pine Valley local community. Most of the comprehensive-time employees of Pine Valley, including the longtime police main, retired or were being laid off.

The consolidation also gave Pine Hill two private golf courses. The 3.87-sq.-mile Pine Hill Borough was now household to the former Pine Hill Golfing Club, purchased by the Trump Group in 2009 and renamed Trump National Golfing Club Philadelphia.

“Before we ended up a blue-collar community and we experienced (Trump Nationwide Golf Club Philadelphia),” Inexperienced instructed NJ Progress Media. “Now, we’re still blue collar but we have equally.

“The key force back residents have is, ‘Why just can’t we participate in golfing there?’”

The median residence price in Pine Hill is $135,000, according to current census info. The ordinary evaluation in Pine Valley is virtually $600,000.

Environmentally friendly stated most of the existing Pine Valley club users do not linger in town immediately after a spherical, and the 10 people who basically are living there frequently maintain a very low profile.

“Day in and out, we really don’t know who most of the inhabitants are,” mentioned Eco-friendly, a beverage organization IT manager. “We may well see them at the community Wawa.”

Inexperienced mentioned he is aware Michael Kennedy, the previous mayor of Pine Valley. They attend the similar church, St. Simon Inventory Parish in nearby Berlin Borough. He stated it was not abnormal to see him at Mass. Attempts by NJ Advance Media to achieve Kennedy were not productive.

Eco-friendly claimed he feels Pine Valley inhabitants voted past drop to consolidate, in section, since of the time dedication necessary to provide on the Borough Council and other boards.

Eco-friendly stated there are 17 properties and 3 resident “dormitories,” similar to motels, in Pine Valley now. Which is 3 much less residences than the 23 that ended up cited in the general public files from 2019.

Eco-friendly mentioned he thinks the golf club is phasing out housing, but referred even further concerns to the club President Charley Raudenbush, who did not answer to multiple requests for comment from NJ Advance Media for this article.

Inexperienced explained he is assured there was no pending litigation in opposition to the borough of Pine Valley ahead of the two boroughs consolidated, incorporating he reported he only sees an upside to including a second private golf club to the borough.

Trump Nationwide Golf Club Philadelphia, though also non-public, is not just about as unique, or remarkably rated, as Pine Valley in golf publications. Pine Valley was rated initial between 100 program in The usa by Golf Digest in 2021. Augusta Nationwide, the house of the Masters Event, was rated No. 2. There had been no Trump golf programs rated in the major 100. Trump Countrywide Golfing Club Philadelphia was ranked No. 20 of 25 in New Jersey by the journal, although Pine Valley was ranked No. 1.

Inexperienced claimed previous President Donald Trump did not check out the assets even though he was in business office. But previous Vice President Dan Quayle routinely flew in by helicopter to Pine Valley when he was in office environment, and Environmentally friendly was frequently on hand. He was a volunteer firefighter and they were being needed to be on responsibility in case of unexpected emergency.

“He would appear in and land on the observe selection,” Green stated. “All of sudden, the Secret Assistance would occur in and be everywhere you go. It was something to see.”

Environmentally friendly explained he at the time caddied for “a man who received the U.S. Open up,” but couldn’t don’t forget his title. He stated he also carried the bag for former Flyers star Rick Tocchet.

He stated he obtained the position there from his brother-in-legislation, who acquired his career from Green’s father-in-law. He mentioned they’ve swapped tales in excess of the several years about the well known persons they’ve witnessed or heard about passing through.

“There applied to be a Catholic church two blocks from the back entrance,” Eco-friendly reported. “People explained it was not that abnormal to see Bob Hope and Frank Sinatra in there on a Sunday before they teed off.”

There ended up also tales about the gangster Al Capone participating in the system in the 1930s. A hideaway he was rumored to have, a 36-acre estate in Pine Hill overlooking the training course, bought for $1.3 million in 2019.

“It has been a excellent practical experience, and at the conclude of the working day, it worked out very well for everybody,” Eco-friendly stated.

Make sure you subscribe now and support the regional journalism you rely on and rely on.

Monthly bill Duhart may well be achieved at [email protected].